The Rejected or Neglected Child in Your Class

Ideally, the classroom is a place where everyone is valued and accepted. In reality, this is seldom the case. Some children seem to be socially gifted - they know how to work and play with others and for the most part, they are popular and well liked. For other, less fortunate children, the social world of the classroom, and perhaps more importantly, the playground is a black hole. They don't know the unwritten rules that others seem to know without being told and therefore are constantly breaking them - which leads to being left out, or worse, actively disliked. Rejected children are not only unhappy, they are also more likely to be bullied and to develop aggressive tendencies themselves. How can we, as teachers help these children? Here are some ideas to consider.

Rejected and neglected
First, it is helpful to keep in mind that children with poor social skills generally fall into two categories. Rejected children are actively disliked by their peers. They tend to behave in ways that make them difficult to be around. They may dominate games, they may cheat or refuse to share, they may name call or manipulate. Neglected children are not actively disliked, they just aren't noticed. They are often shy and withdrawn and because they don't put forth the effort to make friends, they may not have any. A neglected child may also just be really different in the why he or she behaves - not aggressive or offensive, just so different that other children don't really understand and relate to that child.  At the bottom of this post is a way to identify neglected and rejected children in in your class.

One friend makes a world of difference
Just having one friend can make such a difference in the life of a rejected or neglected child. Try pairing these kids up with particularly kind children. Pairing two neglected kids together could also work, but avoid pairing a rejected and a neglected child together. Perhaps a friendship will blossom. One thing that can help is to find something that a rejected or neglected student has in common with another student as a starting point. Perhaps they both enjoy a particular video game or are both interested in endangered animals. Generally, both rejected and neglected children do better in one-on-one situations than in groups.

Entering a group is an important skill
Imagine a group of children are playing a game at recess. Another child wants to play too. Here is what successful children do when entering a group:

  • They watch the group for a few minutes to understand the dynamics and the game being played. Then they jump right in taking a small role in the game. For example if it is an informal game of kickball, they take an outfield position. They do not demand to play one of the bases or to be the next one to kick.
  • They may simply ask to play, but they do so either without conditions, or they offer to play a part that is not very desirable For example if the game is an imagination game and no one wants to be a minor character, the new new player may offer to play that part. They also happily take their place at the end of the line if it is that kind of a game.
Unsuccessful children may:
  • Enter the game and demand to play the best position or part of the game or for it to be his or her turn next or ask for "cuts" from other players in line. 
  • Enter the game and then try to change the rules to a version he or she likes better.
  • Enter the game and complain about the way the game is being played or about how another player is playing. 
  • Enter the game and cheat or dominate the game.
  • Stand near the game watching, but never enter the game or ask to join it. 
Teaching children how to enter a group can be really helpful. Role playing might be one way to do this or if you have playground duty, watching group dynamics and making small suggestions could also help. Policing the situation is not helpful to the rejected child. For example, lecturing the other children about how unfair they are being. It will only make the rejected child more disliked. For some ideas about helping children work in groups please see Making Group Work, Work

Counseling can help
If your school is blessed enough to have a counselor that can help with social skills training, by all means take advantage of it. Perhaps the parents would be open to suggestions that they find a counselor privately. Once child's social reputation has been established, it is very difficult to change, but not impossible.



How to analyze your class social hierarchy
I learned how to do this when I was writing a college paper on children's status heiracrchies Please be aware that doing this could be somewhat unethical and so you very well may not want to do it. But the results are interesting and can be useful. To find where your students stand socially in your classroom, make a chart with all of your student's names across the top and listed down the left side. Ask your students to name three classmates they would like to be in a group with and three that would be challenging for them to be grouped with. I did this one time with third graders on a questionnaire about field trips that asked several questions (where would you most like to go, what are some good field trip rules etc.) including one about groups. I required silence during the task and immediately moved into a math lesson afterwards with the hope that it would be forgotten by recess. 

For each student, find his or her name at the top of your chart, go down the column and put circles in the cells for the three children he or she wanted to be grouped with and Xs for the three he or she did not want to be grouped with. Do the same for every child's answers. Then look at each child's row across the chart. Children who have a lot of circles in their rows are popular, those with a lot of Xs are rejected and any child with no Xs or circles is probably neglected.  You may find other interesting patterns as well. Hopefully, you can use the data to subtly help your rejected and neglected children. 

Helping rejected children is not easy. Do you have more ideas to add?

5 comments:

Jennifer Knopf said...

I usually make a sociogram of my class - I ask each student to name 2 people from class they would invite to a party if they could. I've never asked about who they wouldn't want to invite though.

I then create a graphical representation of the data using a circle for each child. The lines between the circle indicate who each child chose. This enables me to see if my class is divided along gender lines, who are the "king" and "queen" of the class as well as any cliques (3 students who all choose each other) and outcasts. I think it is an invaluable tool, although I would not show parents of course! I use the sociogram to group my students at tables, to pair them for small group work and to give to our counselor if she's working with any of my students.

I think just having the awareness helps me be a more sensitive teacher, so I do it ever year regardless of whether I have behavior problems in the class.

Thanks for the post, I think it's so important for teachers to teach social skills as well as academics!

Jennifer @ Herding Kats In Kindergarte

Rachel Lynette said...

I really like your sociogram - so visual. Thanks also for mentioning how valuable a tool like this can be in grouping and partnering students. I agree that social skills is an important part of what teachers do.

-Rachel

Robin Shapiro said...

I think this is an unethical and misguided process. Teachers are not generally qualified to design, administer, or interpret social and psychological tests, and the assumptions a teacher makes on the basis of a one-time half-understood instrument can be damaging to students.

At least, that's what the child psychiatrist told my parents after my third grade teacher assessed me as "asocial" and "rejected" on the basis of a single sociogram. (In case you're wondering, the psychiatrist assessed me as a healthy kid with some asynchronous development -- very slow in some physical skills, very fast in some intellectual areas. I'm now a successful, happy, middle-aged mother, wife, and professional educator.)

I agree that some social skills work can be appropriate in the classroom, but please -- if you feel the need to flag this might be unethical -- just abandon the questionable practice right away. In early grades, you can bring in books about friendship and social stories. You can randomly assign seating or table groups. But plese, don't use tests you are not qualified to interpret! If you would never show it to a parent, if you think it might be unethical, just don't do it!

Rachel Lynette said...

Robin,

I think you bring up some totally valid points, and I too question the ethics of this particular method, as I said in my post. I really like your comment about how if you wouldn't share it with parents, you shouldn't do it. That is probably a good evaluative tool and yet...

I still think I got value from the one time I did do it and I wasn't using it to diagnose students, simply to see how they were perceived by their peers.

Always good to get different opinions - thanks for commenting!

Anonymous said...

I love that a teacher would care enough to do a sociogram, and this comes from a mother who most likely has a "rejected" child. Parents often know these things or suspect them and want a clearer picture with the help of the school. It is a hard truth to accept, but if delivered by a teacher who is proactive enough to explore and address it, I would think most parents would be accepting and appreciative. I would be thrilled!

Teaching Resources

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
 
Pin It button on image hover